Venture capitalist Peter Thiel, famous for financing facebook, is giving $100,000 to 20 young entrepreneurs under 20…each.
watch the interview on 60 minutes
He claims that higher education is, for most, a waste of time and money. American kids and their parents have been convinced that a Bachelor’s degree is the only credential that matters. But those who have a Bachelor’s degree know that a Masters degree or Ph.D are the only credential that matters.
I believe credentials are important. I believe a college education is important...but only if you can afford it. Here’s a quick test to see if you can:
Do you have at least $20,000 in extra cash, right now, in your bank account/backyard?
No?
Then you can’t afford college.
Debt is slavery. Slavery is death. Death sucks.
Theil’s anti-education stance is taking plenty of criticism, however. Professor Vivek Wadhwa argues that “if you don’t even have a basic education, you are beyond hope.” About kids with ideas he says, “ideas are a dime-a-dozen, what makes you successful is being able to take that idea, turn it into an invention, then turn that into a company.”
I agree. I also think that’s exactly what Theil’s program is designed to do. It’s what my program is designed to do.
There are four things missing from this discussion. One is the topic of self-education. The fact is that people who want to learn…will, school or no school. Curious and determined minds seek out information which, today is free, instantly available via the internet and highly accessible though the public library system.
Number two is the fact that the kids Theil’s mentoring are special. They’re IQ scores are well above average and their technical skills beyond what mine or yours will ever be. So much so that part of Theil’s program includes training in social intelligence, things like how to have a conversation, read body-language, and shake someone’s hand.
The third issue that should be addressed is the pervasive sense of uncertainty in today’s youth. Theil says that higher education is the right path if your life-plan is to be a professor, doctor, or scientist. If that’s not part of your path then you should do something else.
Life plan? I don’t know many 18-year-olds, or 28-year-olds for that matter, who have a life plan. Those who do worry me. For better or worse today’s motto is live for today…YOLO.
We’ve got to give these kids practical ways to understand their individual strengths, identify their passions and then teach them how to amplify and apply them. Success will follow whether they go on in school or not. Run-of-the- mill guidance counseling isn’t going to cut it. I found it to be more of a liability than an asset.
Finally, let’s say college is not for you. You’re not Bill Gates Jr. and you don’t have $30,000+ to spend but you do want to be educated. Not only so you can get a job but so you can appreciate life, the world around you, and especially the world inside you. Knowledge is a birthright.
Finally, we have to address the problem that there is no relevant institution to fill the void that stands between university’s and trade schools. Is it homeschooling? For adults? Can you get a credential for life experience? Perhaps. Maybe that infrastructure and culture is already growing.
Students should have access to an unbiased mentor or coach (not just a teacher or counselor) who is capable of guiding students through the ins-and-outs of developing an education or career plan, and ideally a business plan. They need to be encouraged to dream big, hatch big ideas, communicate those ideas, accept constructive feedback, and take action.
Theil says that credentials don’t matter. And that’s probably true for the 20 under 20. But for B students like me, a strong foundation in business, life experience , a taste of the liberal arts, as well as resilience training is what’s needed. Credentials or not, I want my kids to get a better education than I did.